Talk:If It Smells Like an Ed/@comment-137.99.172.215-20130204221311

Reasons why most people dislike this episode:

1. Despite everyone except Sarah laughing at Jimmy (even Edd and Nazz, which is highly OOC of them), Jimmy went after all three of the Eds and them alone, even though only Eddy deserved getting punished. He should have either gone after Eddy alone, or gone after everyone except Sarah. This is the reason why the "guilt by association" that Ed and Edd got in this episode is more irritating than usual.

2. The hypocrisy. Everyone except Sarah laughed at Jimmy, and yet they decided to beat up the Eds for the things they accused them of.

3. In scenarios similar to this episode, the wrongfully accused gets a chance to clear their name. This did not happen at all for the Eds, and the episode comes off as extremely mean-spirited (moreso than others) as a result.

4. Jonny. He was tied up and covered and jujubes by Jimmy, and therefore should have told the others what he did, thus clearing the Eds' names of that particular deed. However, he did not, and even threw fruits at the Eds. That was probably because he thought Edd wiped off Plank's mouth, but still.

5. Jimmy USED Rolf as a patsy for this plot. That's just horrible.

6. Jimmy's deal with the Kankers. A good number of people LOATHE their actions towards the Eds, and the deal made the Eds' settling for the kids' punishment pointless, since the Kankers get them anyways.

7. Jimmy got away with it without any major consequences. Sure, he slipped on a banana peel, but that's not good enough.